d-bis/metamask-integration
4
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity
Files
25c96e210a1f038e8137e6d0541945a2fbf8fcbb
metamask-integration/docs/SECURITY_AUDIT_PREPARATION.md
defiQUG 25c96e210a chore: sync submodule state (parent ref update) 
Made-with: Cursor
2026-03-02 12:14:14 -08:00

5.1 KiB
Raw Blame History

Security Audit Preparation - Smart Accounts

Date: 2026-01-26
Network: ChainID 138 (SMOM-DBIS-138)

Overview

This document outlines the security audit preparation for Smart Accounts Kit integration contracts.

Contracts to Audit

1. AccountWalletRegistryExtended

File: contracts/smart-accounts/AccountWalletRegistryExtended.sol

Key Functions:

  • linkSmartAccount() - Links smart account to fiat account
  • isSmartAccount() - Checks if wallet is smart account
  • setSmartAccountFactory() - Updates factory address
  • setEntryPoint() - Updates EntryPoint address

Security Concerns:

  • Access control (role-based)
  • Input validation
  • Smart account verification
  • Reentrancy protection

2. Smart Accounts Kit Contracts (External)

Contracts:

  • EntryPoint (ERC-4337)
  • AccountFactory
  • Paymaster (optional)

Note: These are external contracts from MetaMask Smart Accounts Kit. Review their security audits.

Audit Checklist

Access Control

  • Role-based access control implemented correctly
  • Admin functions protected
  • Role assignment verified
  • Role revocation works correctly

Input Validation

  • Zero address checks
  • Parameter validation
  • Array bounds checking
  • Type validation

Smart Account Verification

  • Contract detection works correctly
  • Smart account validation
  • Address format validation
  • Duplicate prevention

Reentrancy Protection

  • Reentrancy guards in place
  • State changes before external calls
  • Checks-Effects-Interactions pattern

Gas Optimization

  • Gas-efficient storage patterns
  • Loop optimization
  • Unnecessary operations removed

Event Emission

  • All state changes emit events
  • Event parameters complete
  • Indexed parameters for filtering

Known Security Considerations

1. Smart Account Verification

Risk: EOA could be mistaken for smart account

Mitigation:

  • Check extcodesize > 0
  • Verify contract has code

2. Factory Address Updates

Risk: Malicious factory address

Mitigation:

  • Admin-only function
  • Verify factory address before update
  • Consider timelock for critical updates

3. EntryPoint Address Updates

Risk: Malicious EntryPoint address

Mitigation:

  • Admin-only function
  • Verify EntryPoint address
  • Consider timelock for critical updates

Testing Requirements

Unit Tests

  • Access control tests
  • Input validation tests
  • Smart account detection tests
  • Edge case tests

Integration Tests

  • End-to-end flow tests
  • Multi-contract interaction tests
  • Failure mode tests

Fuzz Tests

  • Fuzz input parameters
  • Fuzz state transitions
  • Fuzz edge cases

Invariant Tests

  • State invariants
  • Access control invariants
  • Data consistency invariants

Audit Deliverables

1. Code Documentation

  • NatSpec comments on all functions
  • Architecture documentation
  • Security considerations documented

2. Test Coverage

  • Unit test coverage > 90%
  • Integration test coverage > 80%
  • Fuzz test coverage
  • Invariant test coverage

3. Security Documentation

  • Threat model
  • Security assumptions
  • Known limitations
  • Risk assessment

Recommended Audit Firms

Smart Contract Auditors

  1. Trail of Bits

    • Experience with account abstraction
    • ERC-4337 expertise

  2. OpenZeppelin

    • Smart account experience
    • Access control expertise

  3. Consensys Diligence

    • MetaMask integration experience
    • Security best practices

  4. CertiK

    • Comprehensive audits
    • Formal verification

Audit Scope

In Scope

  • AccountWalletRegistryExtended contract
  • Integration with existing AccountWalletRegistry
  • Smart account linking logic
  • Access control implementation

Out of Scope

  • MetaMask Smart Accounts Kit contracts (external)
  • EntryPoint contract (external, already audited)
  • AccountFactory contract (external, already audited)
  • Paymaster contract (external, optional)

Pre-Audit Checklist

Code Quality

  • Code formatted (forge fmt)
  • No compiler warnings
  • All tests passing
  • Documentation complete

Security

  • Slither analysis run
  • Mythril analysis run
  • Manual security review
  • Known issues documented

Testing

  • Unit tests complete
  • Integration tests complete
  • Fuzz tests complete
  • Coverage > 90%

Post-Audit Actions

1. Address Findings

  • Review audit report
  • Prioritize findings
  • Fix critical issues
  • Fix high-priority issues
  • Document medium/low issues

2. Re-testing

  • Re-run all tests
  • Verify fixes
  • Update documentation

3. Re-audit (if needed)

  • Schedule re-audit for critical fixes
  • Verify all issues resolved

Resources

Last Updated: 2026-01-26

Reference in New Issue View Git Blame Copy Permalink