# Migration Storage Issue - Analysis

**Date:** 2025-01-20  
**Status:** Issue Identified  
**Problem:** Direct migration fails due to storage name mismatch

---

## Problem

Migration of VMs from r630-02 to r630-01 fails with error:
```
ERROR: migration aborted: storage 'thin1' is not available on node 'r630-02'
```

**For VMIDs 7800-7811:**
```
ERROR: migration aborted: storage 'thin4' is not available on node 'r630-01'
```

---

## Root Cause

### Storage Configuration Mismatch

**r630-02:**
- VMs use `thin1` and `thin4` storage
- These storage pools exist on r630-02
- thin1 on r630-02 is a different volume group than thin1 on r630-01

**r630-01:**
- Has `thin1` storage (pve/thin1)
- Does NOT have `thin4` storage
- Storage names are the same but volume groups are different

**Issue:** Proxmox migration tries to preserve storage names, but:
- thin1 on r630-02 ≠ thin1 on r630-01 (different VGs)
- thin4 doesn't exist on r630-01

---

## Solutions

### Option 1: Manual Config Move + Storage Migration (Complex)

1. Move VM configs (already done for visibility)
2. Manually copy storage volumes using LVM commands
3. Complex and risky

### Option 2: Backup/Restore (Recommended but has issues)

1. Create backup using vzdump
2. Restore to target node with new storage
3. **Current issue:** vzdump also fails with same error

### Option 3: Enable thin4 on r630-01 (If needed)

If we want to preserve thin4 storage name:
1. Create thin4 storage on r630-01
2. Then migration might work
3. But still has VG mismatch issue

### Option 4: Use Different Storage Names

Migrate VMs to storage with different names:
- VMIDs 100-130 → thin1 on r630-01 (already exists)
- VMIDs 7800-7811 → local or local-lvm on r630-01

**This requires backup/restore method.**

---

## Recommended Solution

### Use vzdump with --remove (if supported) or manual backup

Since vzdump is also failing, we need to:

1. **Check if storage volumes can be accessed directly**
2. **Use alternative backup method**
3. **Or manually copy storage volumes**

### Alternative: Change VM Storage First

1. On r630-02, change VM storage to a compatible storage (like `local`)
2. Then migrate normally
3. Then change storage on target if needed

---

## Next Steps

1. Investigate why vzdump fails (may need to check storage access)
2. Consider using `dd` or `lvconvert` to copy storage volumes
3. Or change VM storage configuration before migration
4. Or use shared storage (NFS) as intermediate

---

**Last Updated:** 2025-01-20  
**Status:** Issue Identified - Solution Investigation Needed
